Hi ccrane, I don't mind putting the name out there of the TTR trade since the sell to close order has already come out and no one is going to make money off of Chris's recommendation now. It's difficult to comment on your idea to hold because I don't know what prices or when you got into the COG calls or turned it into a spread. I sounds like you did it all just yesterday which is a little scary. If you did, I'm sorry. The RSI was already in overbought territory and it would have been better to wait for the next opportunity. If I'm understanding you right, you want to hold onto both the long and the short call hoping that the call will become worthless (or just less) so you can buy it to close for a profit and then sell to close your long call. All I can say to it really is Chris gave the sell and you should follow it. Anything beyond that is your own speculation and risk. You're capped on your gains anyways because the short call will eat up any profits (or at least some) from its strike price upward that your long call would gain. If you wait for it to drop, your long call is losing, too, so you might as well close your positions. That's my advice.

I'm going to throw a little sidenote in here though just for "huh, look at that" value. In looking at the 3 year chart I noticed that every single time the RSI moved into OB territory and back out while the price was making a NEW HIGH, the stock price retraced to previous resistance, but when it only got close to OB but not through, it had an increased tendency to break back below previous resistance and return to previous support or near to it. SO, what I'm calling (depending on the next day or two's price movement relative to its new high) is a return to the $42 to $43 price level after which we'll see what it does. To be honest, I'm tempted if the price holds to a new resistance that it would be neat-o to buy a put and make money on the way down, but I'm just going to watch it. Reason being is, buying a put on a stock in one of the strongest sectors with strong relative strength is completely against the CRISS method. So I'll watch it and be amused if it does what I think or it'll do the opposite and I'll be glad I didn't act on it. The odds are against me in this one, or at least not stacked enough. I'll wait for the next opportunity...